Penn. Sen. Arlen Specter
to Switch to Democratic Party
By Chris Cillizza and Paul Kane
Washington Post Staff
Writers
Tuesday, April 28, 2009 5:43 PM
Pennsylvania Sen. Arlen Specter will switch parties and run for reelection in
November 2010 as a Democrat, he announced today, a decision that could have
wide-ranging consequences for the Senate and President Obama's agenda.
Specter told reporters that he received a "bleak" poll Friday from his
advisers that showed virtually no chance of him winning in the GOP primary next
spring against Pat Toomey, a former Republican House member who recently led the
conservative Club for Growth.
He said that the loss of several hundred thousand GOP voters who left the
party in 2008 to vote in the Democratic presidential primary left the
Pennsylvania Republican Party too conservative to support a moderate such as
him. "I have found myself increasingly at odds with the Republican Party,"
Specter said.
After more than 28 years in the Senate, Specter acknowledged he was "not
prepared to have that record" obliterated by the conservative primary
electorate. He reached the decision over the weekend in consultation with his
family and top aides, many of whom are staying with him despite his party
switch.
He said informed Republican and Democratic Senate leaders about dinnertime
last night.
The move brings Democrats to 59 seats in the Senate, just one shy of the 60
they need to exert filibuster-proof control over the chamber. In Minnesota,
Democrat Al Franken holds a 312-vote lead over former senator Norm Coleman (R), but Coleman has appealed the result to the state
Supreme Court. Oral arguments in the case are expected to begin in June.
Nonetheless, Specter remains an independent voice on many issues, opposing a
union organizing bill that is key to many labor groups and rejecting Obama's
choice to run a key legal advisory section of the Justice Department. "I will
not be an automatic 60th vote," he said.
Specter's announcement, coming on the eve of Obama's 100th day in office,
sent shockwaves through political circles.
Specter called the White House this morning to inform Obama of his decision
but the president was busy getting his daily economic briefing. When he received
a note shortly afterward that Specter was switching parties, the president
quickly returned the call, recalled a top adviser who was in the room at the
time.
Specter said he received the president's full blessing to run in the
Democratic primary largely uncontested next April. "He said he would support me,
come to Pennsylvania to campaign for me," Specter said.
Vice President Biden, a long-time friend of Specter's who had counseled him
about switching parties, issued a statement late this afternoon saying, "I
welcome my old friend to the Democratic Party. Senator Arlen Specter is a man of
remarkable courage and integrity. I know he will remain a powerful and
independent voice for Pennsylvania and the country."
Republicans immediately sought to cast Specter's move as nothing more than
the politics of self-preservation. "Let's be honest -- Senator Specter didn't
leave the GOP based on principles of any kind," said Republican National
Committee Chairman Michael Steele. "He left to further his personal political
interests because he knew that he was going to lose a Republican primary due to
his left-wing voting record."
Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid (D-Nev.) said Specter told him
last night that he was likely to make the shift, then called the Democratic
leader this morning to confirm that his decision was final. Reid credited Biden
for playing an important behind-the-scenes role in softening Specter's
resistance. Reid also said he and Specter "have had a long dialogue about his
place in an evolving Republican Party" and praised his willingness to "work in a
bipartisan manner, put people over party, and do what is right for
Pennsylvanians and all Americans."
Specter will receive his seniority among Democrats as if he had been elected
as a Democrat in 1980, when he rode into office on the coattails of Ronald
Reagan's conservative revolution. That effectively means Specter will become
chairman of a key subcommittee on the Appropriations Committee, probably the one
overseeing the departments of Labor and Health and Human Services. Specter also
acknowledged that becoming full appropriations committee chairman -- something
that could take another six to 10 years -- "is something I'd like to attain."
As the Senate was wrapping up a procedural vote on popular anti-fraud
legislation yesterday evening -- a vote forced upon the chamber by a bloc of
hard-line Senate conservatives -- Specter stood by the doorway at the north end
of the chamber leading to Reid's office suite on the second floor of the
Capitol. According to a Democratic observer, Reid and Specter left the chamber
together, entering the majority leader's offices for a private huddle in which
Specter confirmed the party switch.
After making the announcement today, Specter turned aside all questions from
reporters as he cast a vote on the Senate floor, then joined his wife Joan and
son Shanin in the Senate dining room for lunch. He then made a five-minute
appearance in the weekly Republican luncheon in the Lyndon Baines Johnson Room,
off the Senate floor, where his entrance was greeted with a stony silence.
Specter's political standing in Pennsylvania has become increasingly tenuous
in recent years. His track record as a moderate combined with the shrinking
Republican base in the Keystone State were likely to make a general election
difficult, and Toomey, who came within two points of defeating Specter in the
2004 primary, is running again. Polling showed him with a double-digit edge over
Specter in a GOP primary.
The move was the latest blow to an already staggering GOP. Senate Republican
leaders appeared ashen at a press conference this afternoon. "Obviously, we are
not happy that Senator Specter has decided to become a Democrat," said Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell (R-Ky.).
Flanked by GOP colleagues who stared straight ahead, McConnell said Specter
visited him in his Senate office late yesterday afternoon "and told me quite
candidly that he'd been informed by his pollster that it would be impossible for
him to be reelected in Pennsylvania as a Republican because he could not win the
primary; and he was also informed by his pollster that he could not get elected
as an independent, and indicated that he had decided to become a Democrat."
Grasping for some positive spin on an otherwise catastrophic setback,
McConnell warned that Specter's defection could cripple Republican efforts "to
restrain the excess that is typically associated with big majorities and
single-party rule." He said the pressure would shift to Democrats from
conservative states to provide the checks and balances that Senate Republicans
would now struggle to provide.
McConnell rejected Specter's assertion that the Republican Party had shifted
so far to the right that moderate lawmakers were no longer viable candidates in
swing states. "This is not a national story. This is a Pennsylvania story,"
McConnell said. He said Specter "came to our meeting and talked to us, indicated
to me yesterday . . . and again this morning, that he didn't have any problem
whatsoever with the way he'd been treated by the Republican conference here in
the Senate."
Other moderate Republicans acknowledged they, too, have been approached about
changing parties. Sen. Olympia Snowe and Susan Collins, the Maine Republicans who along with Specter
provided the three pivotal votes for Obama's $787 billion stimulus legislation,
both said today they have been approached. Neither would comment about how
recent the overtures were, although Collins said she has been asked roughly four
times during her 12 years in the Senate to consider becoming a Democrat.
"It's something I would never do," she said.
Snowe called Specter's decision "devastating news" for Republicans,
particularly Northeastern Republicans who have almost vanished in the Senate
during the past decade. "Many Republicans feel alienated and disaffected from
the party," Snowe said. "It just helps nourish a culture of exclusion and
alienation."
Snowe recalled then-Sen. James Jeffords of Vermont, who switched from being a
Republican to an independent caucusing with Democrats in 2001. That was a more
dramatic switch that flipped power from Republicans to Democrats in the chamber.
"Frankly, the party never woke up from that event," she said.
Sen. Lindsey Graham (R-S.C.), a prominent conservative who was John McCain's staunchest supporter in his 2008 GOP presidential
campaign, warned that the party has become regionalized in its mentality. "We
have to find places in the party for people who couldn't win in South Carolina,"
he told reporters.
In his remarks to reporters, Specter flashed one brief moment of anger when
asked about the role the national Republican Party played in his decision,
suggesting his rematch against Toomey will be one filled with a personal
vendetta.
He complained about inaction by GOP leaders in Washington when social and
fiscal conservatives -- largely funded by the group Club for Growth --
challenged moderate Republicans in primaries. He cited four different races in
which the Club for Growth had weighed in and helped a conservative challenger.
Each of those seats -- in Maryland, Michigan, New Mexico and Rhode Island -- is
now held by a Democrat.
"There ought to be a rebellion, there ought to be an uprising," he said.
Senior White House officials said the decision to switch was Specter's, and
he was not lobbied heavily by members of Obama's administration.
"Everyone wanted to give him the space to work things out for himself," a top
White House aide said. "We did not dispatch anyone with a basket of goodies."
The one exception was the vice president. In the 10 weeks since the president
signed the stimulus bill, Biden has met with Specter face-to-face six times and
talked on the phone at least eight times, advisers said.
People close to Biden said the vice president has been urging Specter to make
the switch for years. But they said the conversations intensified during the
past several weeks as Biden watched political developments in Pennsylvania.
"They certainly talked about the fact that both the vice president and the
president would be happy to go to bat for Sen. Specter in every way possible," a
top adviser to Biden said.
As Biden pressed his case, aides said he "regularly informed" Obama about the
conversations, telling the president recently that he was cautiously optimistic
about the prospects.
" 'I talked to Arlan,' " Biden would tell the president, one aide recalled. "
'Still working on him. Still working on him.' [Obama] was obviously aware," the
aide recalled.
Specter tried to call Biden early this morning to inform him before news
leaked. But aides said the two were unable to connect because Biden was in Texas
for an event at the National Domestic Violence Hotline Center.
They talked later in the day.
It was not immediately clear what Specter's decision would do to the
Democratic field in next year's Senate race in Pennsylvania. Joe Torsella, the
former head of the National Constitution Center, was already seeking the
Democratic nomination and raised roughly $600,000 for his bid in the first three
months of 2009.
Toomey becomes the odds-on favorite to be the Republican nominee. Toomey held
the competitive 15th district for three terms before giving up his seat to
challenge Specter in the 2004 primary. He is a favorite of conservatives in the
state, but it remains unclear how competitive he will be given the clear
advantage Democrats now enjoy in Pennsylvania.
Assuming the court sides with Franken in Minnesota, it will mark the first
time since the 95th Congress -- 1977 to 1979 -- that Democrats have controlled
60 or more Senate seats.
Texas Sen. John Cornyn, head of the National Republican Senatorial
Committee, said in a statement that the GOP would seek to make the 2010 election
a referendum on whether voters wanted Democrats to have unchecked control of
Congress. "While this presents a short-term disappointment, voters next year
will have a clear choice to cast their ballots for a potentially unbridled
Democrat super-majority versus the system of checks-and-balances that Americans
deserve," Cornyn said. Earlier this month, Cornyn wrote a letter to Pennsylvania
Republicans urging them to rally around Specter, calling him the only GOP
nominee who could hold the seat.
Staff writers Shailagh Murray and Michael D. Shear contributed to this
report.